Best Pizza In Steubenville Ohio

Are you a pizza lover on the hunt for the best slice in Steubenville, Ohio? Look no further! This charming city on the banks of the Ohio River is home to some seriously delicious pizza joints that will satisfy your cravings. From classic pepperoni to gourmet specialties, Steubenville’s pizzerias offer a variety of flavors to tickle your taste buds.

Whether you’re cheering on the Big Red, exploring local history, or just passing through, you’ll find a pizza place that feels just right. Family-owned shops honor traditional recipes, while new spots mix things up with innovative toppings and crusts. So get ready to dive into some mouthwatering pizza that’s loved by locals and visitors alike!

We’ll guide you to the top spots where the sauce is savory, the cheese stretches for miles, and the crust is just the way you like it. These are the pizzerias that have everyone talking. Steubenville may be known for its history and culture, but its pizza scene is not to be overlooked. So grab a napkin and let’s discover the best pizza in Steubenville, Ohio, together!

A Slice of Steubenville: The Hunt for the Best Pizza

If you’re on the quest for top-notch pizza in Steubenville, you’ve got to know where to start. One of the first places to check out is a little spot that’s been serving piping hot pies for generations. The locals rave about it, and once you take a bite, you’ll understand why.

Another must-try is the pizzeria that puts a creative twist on their pizzas. Imagine slices loaded with unexpected toppings like zesty barbeque chicken or tangy feta cheese. It’s a hit with anyone looking for something out of the ordinary.

Don’t forget about the restaurant that’s all about fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their dough is made from scratch every day, and they use the ripest tomatoes for their homemade sauce. This place is perfect if you’re all about that fresh taste.

To top off your pizza tour, there’s a location that’s famous for their thick, chewy crusts. It’s a total game-changer for anyone who loves their pizza with a bit of a bite. Plus, they’ve got a secret blend of spices that they sprinkle on every pizza, making their flavor unmatched.

Pizza in Steubenville isn’t just food; it’s a way to connect with friends and family. Whether it’s sharing a large pie at the end of a soccer game or grabbing a quick slice after school, it brings people together. So, while you’re tasting your way through the city, you’ll also be making memories that last a lifetime.

Be sure to check out these Steubenville favorites and decide for yourself which is the best. Each place has its own unique charm and flavors, and who knows, you might just find your new go-to pizza spot!

Ready to grab a slice? Check out these pizzerias and share your favorite with us! If you need help finding them, just ask any local – they know where the good stuff is! To make it easier, you can also look them up online. Here’s a link to get you started: Best Pizza in Steubenville on Yelp.

Criteria for Judging

Imagine biting into a warm, cheesy slice of pizza, with the perfect amount of toppings and a crust that’s baked just right. That’s what you’ll find at Steubenville’s popular pizza places. Each spot has its own secret recipe and style, making each visit a new adventure.

Some restaurants use brick ovens for that authentic, fire-baked flavor. Others swear by their generations-old dough recipe. You can taste the tradition in every bite. And it’s not just about taste—these pizzerias have a cozy vibe that makes you feel like you’re part of the family.

Toppings matter, and in Steubenville, you’re spoiled for choice. Whether you love your pizza loaded with veggies, piled high with various meats, or kept simple with just cheese, there’s a place for you. Kids and adults alike can find their perfect pie, making it a great meal for the whole family.

It’s easy to see why locals are proud of their pizza. When you walk into a Steubenville pizza shop, the aroma of baking pizzas hits you, and you know you’re in for a treat. The folks behind the counter often greet you with a smile, ready to serve up a slice of heaven.

Don’t forget to ask about the daily specials! Many places offer unique combinations or discounts that let you try something new without breaking the bank. Who knows, you might just discover your new favorite pizza.

So, next time you’re in town, follow the smell of oregano and melting cheese to one of Steubenville’s pizza parlors. Whether you’re sitting down with friends or grabbing a quick slice on the go, you’re in for some of the best pizza Ohio has to offer.

Local Versus Chain Pizzerias

When searching for the best pizza in Steubenville, not only do the flavors matter, but so does the experience. Think lively places where the energy buzzes and the ovens are always hot.

There’s something about watching your pizza being made that adds to the fun. Many Steubenville pizzerias have open kitchens. You can see the chefs tossing dough and adding toppings. It’s like a show with a delicious ending.

And these aren’t your average pizzas either. Sure, you’ll find classic pepperoni, but also pies topped with gourmet ingredients. How about a pizza with feta cheese, spinach, and olives? Or maybe one with barbecue chicken? Your taste buds won’t get bored.

If you’re having a night in, there’s good news. Many local pizza places deliver right to your door. It’s the same great taste without having to leave your cozy spot at home.

Are you a fan of spicy or sweet? Why not both? Some pizzas come with a drizzle of hot honey. It’s a hit with the locals and might be your new favorite too. Just ask for recommendations.

Getting a good deal can make a great pizza taste even better. Look out for “pizza of the month” deals or lunchtime specials. These can help you save a few bucks and still enjoy Steubenville’s finest.

Remember to save room for dessert. Yep, dessert pizzas! Imagine a sweet crust with chocolate, marshmallows, or fruit. It’s the perfect end to a pizza feast.

So, grab some friends or family and start your pizza journey in Steubenville. With so many options, it’s a quest that’ll keep your appetite happy and your pizza nights exciting!

Importance of Fresh Ingredients

Steubenville takes its pizza seriously. Every crust is rolled out with care, and the sauce is often a secret recipe. People love their local pizza because it feels special and homemade.

Local toppings are big here too. Fresh veggies from nearby farms make the pizzas taste super fresh. And don’t be surprised to find a sprinkle of Ohio cheese on top. It’s all about local pride.

Have you ever tried a white pizza? It’s made without tomato sauce, just garlic, oil, and lots of cheesy goodness. In Steubenville, these are a must-try and they stand out from the usual pizza lineup.

Some pizza spots are legendary in Steubenville. They’ve been around for ages and feel like a part of the family. Everyone’s got a favorite, and they all have stories about why it’s the best.

Don’t forget the crust. Whether you like it thin and crispy or thick and chewy, Steubenville has it all. Each pizza place has its own way of doing things, which means lots of tasty crusts to try.

What about a slice on the go? Steubenville’s pizza shops offer big, gooey slices perfect for a quick bite. It’s a slice of heaven when you’re out and about and need to fill up fast.

What’s cooler than a retro pizza parlor? Steubenville has some with old-school arcade games and cool decor. Pizza’s always fun, but add in some Pac-Man, and you’ve got a night to remember.

Feeling creative? Some places let you build your own pizza. Pick your crust, sauce, and toppings. It’s a blast to create your own masterpiece, and it tastes even better because you made it just how you like.

Finally, Steubenville’s pizza isn’t just for dinner. Some spots open early to serve breakfast pizzas. Imagine a slice with eggs, bacon, and cheese to kick-start your day. Yum!

Top Pizza Places in Steubenville, OH

Pizza fans in Steubenville have a lot to choose from. There are places that have been flipping dough for generations. Families pass their pizza places down like treasures, and everyone’s got a favorite spot.

If you’re looking for a pizza that’s just right for a party, there are places that make giant pies. They’re so big, you might need a truck to get them home! But no worries, they taste amazing.

For those who love a kick, some Steubenville pizzas come with spicy sauce options. These places toss on hot peppers and spicy meats for folks who love heat with their eat.

And if you’re into dipping, don’t miss out on the variety of sauces. Garlic butter and ranch are just the beginning. Dipping your crust makes the last bite as good as the first.

Ever had a dessert pizza? Imagine sweet toppings on a soft, warm crust. After dinner, or as a treat, they’re a sweet way to finish off a pizza meal.

For pizza lovers who like to eat at home, many shops offer delivery. Some even have online ordering. It’s super easy to click and eat without leaving your couch.

And for folks who watch what they eat, there are healthy options too. Whole wheat crusts, vegan cheese, and lots of veggies make for a lighter but still tasty meal.

When the game’s on, nothing beats pizza and friends. A lot of places have big-screen TVs and space for groups. Cheering for your team is better with a slice in your hand.

To sum it all up, Steubenville doesn’t just make pizza; they make memories. Whether you’re sitting down with family, grabbing a quick lunch, or celebrating with friends, the pizza places here are part of what makes the town special.

Family-Owned Favorites

If you love pepperoni, Steubenville’s your spot. The pizza places here pile on slice after slice of spicy, crispy pepperoni. It curls up at the edges, making tiny cups of flavor that are totally addicting.

Veggie lovers aren’t left out, though. There’s a rainbow of fresh produce that goes on top of these pizzas. Sweet peppers, onions, and even artichokes. It’s like a garden on a pizza, and oh so tasty.

Sometimes, pizza places go big. We’re talking stuffed crusts filled with gooey cheese or even more pepperoni. It’s a fun twist that’s super popular with the kids. It’s cheesy on the inside and out!

If you’re into a smoky flavor, you need to try the BBQ chicken pizza. It’s got tangy sauce, tender chicken, and a smoky taste that’ll make your mouth water. Plus, the cheese and onions make it even better.

For the sweet tooth, some spots swirl a little bit of honey on their pizza. Sounds weird, right? But trust us, that little bit of sweetness with salty cheese is an amazing combo.

Ever heard of a taco pizza? It’s like your favorite taco toppings on a pizza crust. Lettuce, tomato, ground beef, and a mountain of cheese. Don’t forget the dollop of sour cream on top!

For an extra special treat, there are dessert pizzas. Picture a chocolate-hazelnut spread with marshmallows, or maybe apple pie toppings. It’s pizza for dessert, and it’s a perfect way to end a meal.

Here’s something cool – some places use a brick oven. This makes the crust super crispy and gives it a charred flavor that’s really unique. It’s a game-changer for pizza crusts.

If you’re ever in Steubenville and craving pizza, you’re in luck. These pizza joints know how to mix up traditional favorites and exciting new flavors. Plus, with so many choices, you can try something new every time!

Award-Winning Pizzerias

One of the top spots to grab a slice in Steubenville is Naples Spaghetti House. Their pizza has a perfect balance of sauce and cheese, and people can’t stop talking about the homemade dough. It’s a family-owned gem that’s been around for years.

Next up is DiCarlo’s Original Pizza. This place is unique because they put the cheese on after they bake the crust and sauce. It melts from the heat of the hot pizza. It’s a cool way to make pizza that’s all their own.

Another local favorite is Capri Sausage and Meatball. They are known for their thick, hearty pizzas with homemade sausage that’s seasoned just right. Plus, their family recipes have been around for ages, making them a staple in town.

At Ray’s Pizza, they’re famous for their thick pepperoni slices that cover the whole pizza. It’s a meat lover’s dream. Plus, the place has a chill vibe, perfect for hanging out with friends.

For those who enjoy a good deal, Giannamore’s Pizza offers a pizza that won’t break the bank. They have a fan favorite called the “Monday special,” which is a hit with the locals. It’s good pizza without spending a lot of cash.

Lastly, you don’t want to miss M&M’s Pizza. This family-run spot keeps it simple but delicious. Their secret sauce and generous toppings leave customers coming back for more.

Steubenville might not be the biggest city, but it sure has a big pizza heart. These places are just the start and there’s so much more to explore for pizza lovers in town!

Hidden Gems

When craving pizza with a twist, head to Froehlich’s Classic Corner. Imagine biting into a crust that’s just the right amount of crispy and chewy. Their toppings are always fresh, and the whole place has a cool, retro vibe.

For those who like their pizza with a side of sports, Damon’s Grill & Sports Bar is the place to be. They serve up some awesome pies. Watching a game while chowing down on a Damon’s pizza is like a double win!

Don’t forget about The Ville Restaurant & Bar. This joint not only has a super friendly atmosphere, but their pizza is top-notch too. They use zesty sauce and a special blend of cheeses that’ll make your taste buds dance.

If you’re out with your family, you’ve got to try Steve’s Fish & Chips. It might sound like a seafood spot, but their pizza is a hidden treasure. It’s got a crust that’s just right and the cheese is oh-so-gooey.

For those on the go, Downtown Bakery is a must. Grab a slice of their pizza for a quick, yummy bite. It’s perfect when you’re in a hurry but still want something delish.

You also can’t count out Iggy’s Pizza. They’ve got a pizza buffet that’ll fill you up without emptying your wallet. It’s a great spot to try a little bit of everything and find your fave.

Beyond the Crust: Community and Culture

Steubenville is known for more than just great pizza – it’s a town with heart. At Naples Spaghetti House, you don’t just get a slice; you get a slice of the community. The friendly staff and cozy decor make it feel like you’re at a friend’s dinner party.

Then there’s Giannamore’s Pizza. This place is a local legend. Their square-cut slices are a hometown tradition. And when you’re eating there, you might just bump into someone you know. It’s a gathering spot for folks who appreciate good food and good company.

Plus, there’s a hidden gem called Capri Sausage and Meatball. Sure, they’re known for their meats, but their pizza is the real deal. It’s a family-run spot, so they treat their customers like family too. You can taste the love in every bite.

When you support these local pizza joints in Steubenville, you’re not just eating, you’re part of the town’s story. Each slice tells a tale of family traditions, Friday night lights, and community pride. So, while you hunt for the best pizza, remember you’re also experiencing the rich culture of Steubenville, Ohio.

Local Pizza History

Steubenville might be known for its rich history, but locals know it’s also a treasure trove of pizza spots where every slice tells a story. Sharing pizza here is not just about the food; it’s about community gatherings and making memories.

Imagine walking into DiCarlo’s Pizza, a place where the scent of baking dough fills the air. This Steubenville classic is famous for their unique hot-and-ready squares with cold toppings. It’s a quirky tradition that brings families together for something out of the ordinary.

Sometimes, a pizza is more than just a meal – it’s a way to celebrate victories. After a hometown football game, fans often crowd into Giannamore’s Pizza. Cheering for your team is even better with a mouthwatering piece of their famous pie in hand.

And let’s talk about Napoli’s Pizza, where the slices are huge and the smiles are even bigger. Students from nearby schools love to meet here. It’s not just the budget-friendly prices they come for, but the chance to hang out with friends in a chill spot.

Pizza in Steubenville isn’t just a quick snack, it’s a slice of local culture. When people gather around a Napoli’s box, it’s not uncommon to see strangers sharing stories and laughter over a pie. That’s the true flavor of Steubenville: warm, welcoming, and always ready for another slice.

Pizza and Community Engagement

In Steubenville, Ohio, pizza joints are more than just eateries; they’re landmarks where folks from all walks of life intersect. Bella Pizza is one such spot where the sense of community is as tangible as their chewy crusts and savory sauces. The staff knows regulars by name, which says heaps about the homey vibe.

It’s easy to spot groups of Steubenville High School students gathered at Capri Sausage and Meatball, bonding over their shared love for the cheesy, spicy slices. Local sports teams also choose this place to host their banquets, celebrating both wins and losses with Capri’s signature meat lovers’ pizza.

Even out-of-towners who swing by Steubenville for a slice can sense the tight-knit bonds in each of these pizza shops. A family-owned gem, Scaffidi’s Pizza, makes visitors feel like they’re part of the city’s fabric. Here, a simple dinner can turn into an evening filled with delightful chats and encounters with friendly locals.

What’s more, community events often include pizza from these neighborhood favorites. Whether it’s a charity fundraiser or a school function, pizza from places like Mario’s Pizza is a staple that unites people for a cause. There’s a shared understanding here that good pizza and good deeds go hand in hand.

So, when searching for the best pizza in Steubenville, Ohio, one is also looking for places where the roots of community run deep, and the pizza is just a delicious bonus. Every bite is a reminder that in Steubenville, pizza truly brings people together, making every pizzeria a cornerstone of the Valley’s culture.


Choosing the best pizza in Steubenville might be tough with so many great spots. But what makes a pizza place truly stand out is the way it makes you feel. It’s not just about a tasty slice; it’s the laughs shared over a steaming pie, the high fives exchanged after a bite of a zesty pepperoni, and the memories made in those booths and at those tables.

Whether it’s a family night out, a quick bite after a game, or a celebration with friends, Steubenville’s pizza joints add to life’s good moments. Each bite tastes of tradition and the passion for pizza that has been passed down through generations. The crust, the toppings, the sauce – they all tell a story of a city rich in flavor and fellowship.

So when you think back on the best pizza in Steubenville, Ohio, remember it’s about more than just food. It’s a slice of life in this tight-knit community, a piece of what makes the Ohio Valley special. And at the end of the day, it’s about the smiles around the table as you reach for that last slice of pizza perfection.